| September 18, 2008 | Preseason | NY Islanders | Boston | Rechlicz-Fletcher Haley-Marquardt | ||
| September 25, 2008 | Preseason | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Haley-Clackson Sugden-Cote Sugden-Clackson Haley-Downie | ||
| September 27, 2008 | Preseason | Florida | NY Islanders | Glass-Jackman | ||
| October 1, 2008 | Preseason | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Salvador-Sugden Brookbank-Jackman Rupp-Fritz | ||
| October 3, 2008 | Preseason | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Witt-Clarkson Fritz-Brookbank Comrie-Gionta | ||
| October 13, 2008 | Buffalo | NY Islanders | Rivet-Bergenheim Kaleta-Witt Mair-Thompson | |||
| October 25, 2008 | Carolina | NY Islanders | Gleason-Thompson | |||
| October 27, 2008 | NY Rangers | NY Islanders | Voros-Thompson | |||
| November 1, 2008 | Montreal | NY Islanders | Laraque-Fritz | |||
| November 15, 2008 | _ | Ottawa | NY Islanders | Neil-Jackman | ||
| November 17, 2008 | _ | Vancouver | NY Islanders | Davison-Jackman | ||
| November 21, 2008 | _ | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Salvador-Jackman Mottau-Hunter | ||
| November 22, 2008 | _ | NY Islanders | Buffalo | Fritz-Peters | ||
| November 26, 2008 | _ | Pittsburgh | NY Islanders | Godard-Fritz | ||
| November 28, 2008 | _ | NY Islanders | Boston | Witt-Lucic Jackman-Hnidy | ||
| December 6, 2008 | _ | Atlanta | NY Islanders | Thorburn-Jackman Crabb-Campoli | ||
| December 16, 2008 | _ | Washington | NY Islanders | Bradley-Jackman | ||
| December 26, 2008 | _ | Toronto | NY Islanders | Deveaux-Jackman | ||
| December 29, 2008 | _ | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Fritz-Orr Comrie-Dawes | ||
| January 3, 2009 | _ | NY Islanders | San Jose | Jackman-Semenov Weight-Erhoff | ||
| January 15, 2009 | _ | Boston | NY Islanders | Thornton-Jackman | ||
| January 17, 2009 | _ | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Salvador-Jackman | ||
| January 29, 2009 | _ | NY Islanders | Atlanta | Jackman-Thorburn | ||
| February 3, 2009 | _ | Tampa Bay | NY Islanders | Lecavalier-Jackman | ||
| February 7, 2009 | _ | NY Islanders | Tampa Bay | Jackman-Smaby Guerin-Malone | ||
| February 14, 2009 | _ | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Jackman-Asham | ||
| February 18, 2009 | _ | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Bergenheim vs Prucha | ||
| February 19, 2009 | _ | Carolina | NY Islanders | Conboy-Jackman Larose-Comrie | ||
| March 10, 2009 | _ | NY Islanders | Toronto | Jackman vs Oreskevic Gervais-Stempniak | ||
| March 12, 2009 | _ | NY Islanders | Montreal | Rechlicz-Kostopolous Jackman-Stewart | ||
| March 21, 2009 | NY Islanders | Ottawa | Rechlicz-Fisher | |||
| March 25, 2009 | Minnesota | NY Islanders | Scott-Rechlicz Sheppard-Witt | |||
| March 28, 2009 | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | Powe-Weight Carcillo-Thompson Cote-Rechlicz Jackman-Asham | |||
| April 1,2009 | NY Islanders | Washington | Rechlicz-Erskine Jackman-Schultz | |||
| April 2,2009 | Montreal | NY Islanders | Laraque-Rechlicz Metropolit-Weight | |||
| April 4,2009 | Tampa Bay | NY Islanders | Koci-Fritz Konopka-Rechlicz | |||
| April 7,2009 | NY Islanders | Carolina | Rechlicz-Conboy | |||